Virtual Tour
USA New York Fire Island, NY Ocean Bay Park Listing #21955

11 Cayuga Street - Ocean Bay Park, NY

12 reviews
Max occupancy: 10 1 Queen Bed, 2 Double Bed, 4 Twin Bed 4 bedrooms 1.5 bathrooms Dog-friendly  (30 lb weight limit) 
11 Cayuga St, Ocean Bay Park, NY 11770

Worry-free booking

Enjoy peace of mind with flexible options to change or cancel your trip.

If your check-in date is at least 30 days away, you can reschedule your trip, cancel and receive 100% of the cost as a Future Stay Credit, or cancel for a refund (minus the booking fee).

Expert cleaning

Professional housekeepers clean and stock each home, using an EPA-approved disinfectant.

Local support

Each trip is backed by 24/7 customer support and local teams everywhere we operate.


Many Vacasa homes use smart locks or lockboxes for a smooth, contactless check-in.

Newly remodeled home w/ a sun deck in a great location - dogs welcome!

Fair Housing Notice

This classic Fire Island vacation home boasts a brand new kitchen with custom cabinetry and stainless steel appliances, beautifully tiled bathrooms, and hardwood floors. Bright and sunny interior with an open concept kitchen/living/dining area. The beautiful sliding glass door leading to an enormous wrap around deck where you can enjoy an amazing amount of sunshine! Amazing outdoor dining with two outdoor dining tables with seating for 10 people. This home features four bedrooms, one-and-a-half baths, and two spacious outdoor showers. The home is fully equipped with A/C, heat, WiFi, DirectTV Now, BBQ, linens, towels, pots and pans, cookware, dishware, utensils, Keurig coffee maker, toaster oven, dishwasher, washer/dryer, beach chairs, four bikes, a wagon, and much more!

What's nearby:
Ferry service from Bay Shore lands you in the heart of the Ocean Bay Park commercial district, which gives off a bohemian and breezy vibe. Downtown Ocean Bay Park features bay front dining at Schooners and Flynn's, a pizza parlor, ice cream shop, bagel store & deli, grocery store, and a bicycle rental shop.

Things to know:
Free WiFi
This home is only accessible via ferry
The family dogs are welcome with a small nightly fee - 30lbs weight limit
This home has a strict 30 year-old minimum age requirement. This rule does not apply to families with children.
There are strict good neighbor and noise policies for this home in addition to no parties allowed at any time.

This property is managed by Susan Scanlon, Principal Real Estate Broker with Vacasa New York, LLC

You must be 30 years or older to rent this property.



Washer/dryer : Private

Heating & cooling

Central AC

Kitchen & dining









On-site activities

Adult bikes

Tennis court : Shared


Gas grill : Private

Beach chairs


Parking & access

Paid parking only

Safety & accessibility

Disability access

12 reviews

diana s. Aug 2020
The house was clean with all necessary amenities.
The bathrooms and kitchen appeared newly remodeled. The beds were all comfortable and linens were clean. There were two outdoor dining tables and one inside. There were also more than enough beach chairs and bicycles available for use during your stay. Great location with proximity to the beach, ferry, and local market.
Gary K. Jun 2020
Well appointed house as described. Very clean, bright, and comfortable. This lovely house perfectly suited our needs. Wonderful outdoor deck space! We enjoyed all our meals outdoors. Great outdoor space whether you are seeking sun or shade. Would definitely rent again.
Rosa R. Aug 2019
This house is exactly as pictured. Fully stocked with everything you need. Great wrap around porch, two outdoor showers, beach chairs, umbrella washer dryer. The only tiny teeny thing I could say was the couch wasn’t that comfortable. It was a bit more of a bench but who stays inside! I’d rent it again
Erin U. Aug 2019
Nice house near everything.
Kristyn R. Jul 2019
Comfortable and clean, updated and new. We enjoyed our stay here!
Emily D. Jun 2019
This place was absolutely perfect for my family. So close to the beach and the bikes were great for getting us to Ocean Beach for happy hour!!
Donna R. Jun 2018
Wonderfully clean home with everything you could need to relax and enjoy. I am looking forward to staying again.
Joanna C. Jun 2018
The property was a very short walk from the ferry, a few bars/restaurants, the beach, and a corner store with pretty much anything you might need. The home was nicer than we expected, the pictures didn't do it justice. The bedrooms were tiny, but typical for a vacation rental. There was a wagon waiting for us (locked up) at the ferry, which was very useful for bringing back groceries.
Caitlin S. Jun 2018
We enjoyed this lovely cottage during a girls getaway in the beginning of June. We were fortunate enough to have a gorgeous weekend, which made the stay even that much more enjoyable! We arrived to an adorable wagon to use tote our goods back to the house. The house was perfect for the amount of ladies we had. 3 of the rooms consisted of 2 beds each and the 4th a queen. The house looked newly renovated and was extemely clean. There were toiletiries and paperrowls left for us, which were an added bonus.. We were fortunate enough to have a dear visit us while enjoying the deck and took the bikes out for a few jaunts to downtown. The brand new beach chairs were an added bonus and greatly appreciated. The house is conveniently located to everything- a nearby store, beach, restaurants, the ferry and about a mile to downtown.
Jacklyn I. May 2018
The rental was perfect for my group of 10! It was spotless and in a great location - I would definitely recommend!
Jim & Meredith R. Aug 2017
So close to the beach and the bay. Easily sleeps up to 8 people. Large deck is a huge asset because half the time is spent outside. Right near Flynns and pizza/ice cream parlor. Easy 25 minute walk to Ocean Beach.
Lisa A. Jun 2017
We thoroughly enjoyed our stay! The home was clean and showed exactly as advertised! Loved the location and the overall experience! My extremely minor comment is that the blender should probably be replaced. I'm sure its not used often and its kept high up so probably forgotten about when cleaning and think it would probably be a quick fix to just replace it. Otherwise everything was wonderful!