Virtual Tour
USA Florida Florida Keys Islamorada Listing #37441

Casa Cayo - Islamorada, FL

36 reviews
Max occupancy: 6 1 King Bed, 1 Queen Bed, 1 Double Bed, 1 Sofa Bed 2 bedrooms 2.5 bathrooms No pets 
88540 Overseas Hwy, #712, Islamorada, FL 33070

Worry-free booking

Enjoy peace of mind with flexible options to change or cancel your trip.

If your check-in date is at least 30 days away, you can reschedule your trip, cancel and receive 100% of the cost as a Future Stay Credit, or cancel for a refund (minus the booking fee).

Expert cleaning

Professional housekeepers clean and stock each home, using an EPA-approved disinfectant.

Local support

Each trip is backed by 24/7 customer support and local teams everywhere we operate.


Many Vacasa homes use smart locks or lockboxes for a smooth, contactless check-in.

New listing! Bayfront townhouse in yacht club w/ shared pool & private boat slip

You and your group will be spoiled with a stay at Casa Cayo! Newly remodeled in 2020, this bright and beachy townhouse is part of the exclusive Futura Yacht Club, right in the heart of Islamorada. Enjoy the comfortable living area with access out to an inviting balcony, prepare anything from quick snacks to complete dinners in the well-equipped, full kitchen, and dine together at the nearby table with seating for six. Take advantage of the private commercial ice maker, fish cleaning station, deep freezer, and grill.

This home also features a furnished, bay view patio on the ground floor as well as a cozy balcony off the upstairs master bedroom with additional bay views and easy bay access between Tavernier and Snake Creek. Staying here is also an angler's dream as this home is located directly on the water with a private boat slip, and there is easy ocean access between Tavernier and Snake Creek. Also provided are a private, commercial ice maker, fish cleaning station, deep freezer, and a grill. And as for complex amenities, guests will enjoy access to a shared, outdoor pool, tennis courts, basketball courts, a boat slip, dining area with grills, a private beach with Tiki huts, and on-site trailer parking and a boat ramp.

What's nearby:
Just one mile south of this home is Islamorada Founders Park, a 40-acre park offering activities for the whole family including water sports rentals, ball fields, a fishing jetty, a multi-use path, and much more. Additional parks include the Islamorada Library Beach, Anne’s Beach, and the Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park, the site of a former coral rock quarry where you can enjoy shady walk through unique foliage and discover a variety of fossils, less than four miles away. And for visiting cyclists, Islamorada also offers an 18-mile bicycle path that extends the whole length of the village.

Things to know:
Free WiFi
Full kitchen
One sofabed included
Central air conditioning
Two SUP paddleboards and life jackets available
Tennis rackets provided

Property permit ID: DWE5403805; Islamorada No. VR-233

You must be 21 years or older to rent this property.

Property permit ID: DWE5403805; Islamorada No. VR-233



Washer/dryer : Private

Heating & cooling

Central AC

Kitchen & dining






Water view





Cable : Comcast

Wireless router

On-site activities

Pool : Shared

Board games

Tennis court : Shared

Basketball court : Shared


Gas grill : Shared



Beach chairs

Beach towels




36 reviews

Michael G. May 2917
Also property as advertised- we will definitely be staying there again soon !
Matthew L. Sep 2020
We were originally supposed to stay in another rental and got cancelled on day of our arrival, We had no choice to take what was offered to us. Once we arrived we LOVED the place! Super clean and the views were amazing! The only difference from this rental and the other was that both rooms were supposed to have beachfront views. After seeing The amazing things such as Nurse sharks, Manatees, Crab, jelly fish and Tons of other fish From our balconies in the harbor we couldn’t be upset about the previous last minute cancellation. I highly recommend staying here.
Patrick K. Jul 2020
Awesome place to stay. Very clean and welcoming. Incredible view of the water. Great manager also. Very helpful and available to assist. Highly recommend!
Teresa W. Jun 2020
This is a very nice condo and perfect for fisherman. Would recommend upgrading couch and master bed. Everything else was wonderful
Carla W. Dec 2019
My family of 5 stayed at Casa Cayo and had a wonderful stay. We had everything we needed and more. We fished a lot, so the ease of a boatslip, ice maker and freezer right out the front door was perfect. The condo was clean and very nicely decorated. The owner was easy to communicate with and responded promptly. A lot of extras too....board games, tennis rackets, paddle boards.... We will definitely be back!
Jerrie J. Jul 2019
Futura Yacht club in itself is a beautiful, gated community with the most perfect view of every sunset. Jen’s place is gorgeous, well kept, and she has every amenity you can think of! She was so quick to respond to any question we had. It was a great week and everything was just as advertised!
Gary G. Jun 2019
This is our second time staying at Casa Cayo, The condo and the property that it’s on has all the amenities that you need to have an awesome vacation. Bring your boat, food and sunscreen and the owners have thought of everything else. We enjoyed the local restaurants, fishing from our boat and took the opportunity to go out deep-sea fishing with a local captain, along with swimming on the shallow reefs and the local sandbar. You will not be disappointed booking this place, it’s simply perfect !!
Brad P. May 2019
I have been going to the Keys several times a year for that last 20 years. I have stayed in a lot of different locations and homes. This was one of my favorites. The location is great with very easy access to the bay and Atlantic through Snake Creek. It is also very close to Islamorada Sand Bar. The property has everything you need. The boat dockage is directly in front of the condo which makes is very convenient for loading and unloading your boat. Having the onsite boat ramp and trailer storage is very convenient. The home has a ice maker, bait freezer and mini fridge on the bottom level which is very convenient. I would highly recommend It also has a great view of the Bay for evening sunsets. Jen was very accommodating and the property is just like advertised.
Rosemary T. Mar 2019
We have rented homes in many areas of the Keys, but the townhomes at Futura Yacht Club are our favorites. Casa Cayo has it all! The home is well furnished, well equipped, clean and offers everything for a comfortable stay, especially if you are a boater. The dock is directly in front of the townhouse and the lower area has an ice maker, small fridge, a bait freezer, as well as a great high top table and gas grill. The view of the bay from both porches is amazing, especially the sunsets! We will be back!
Leslie J. Mar 2019
The townhouse worked well for our family of four. Everything we needed was available. Very comfortable. Beautiful sunsets from the balcony.
Maureen R. Mar 2019
Everything was very nice. The sunsets were the best, right from the balcony, every night. Lots of things to do, very clean, very relaxing. Boat access was very easy and very nice, having our boat right in front was great. The townhouse was very roomy, clean, and had everything we needed for our family. The pool was nice, large, and warm. Jennifer was great, she was very prepared and we were well informed, and she would answer when ever we needed. I would rent this location again.
John R. Feb 2019
Townhouse was great. Kitchen had everything you need; beds are comfortable; owner responsive to requests. Balconies had a great view of marina and water but fairly small if 4 people wanted to sit out there Gated community was great. Heated pool was actually heated (some felt too warm but I say no). A gathering spot to meet others staying there. Everyone very friendly. Nice tennis courts and pickleball. Sunsets were beautiful and marine life in boat slips plentiful - variety of fish, sharks and even a manatee one day. Weather didn't hurt. Everyday sunny with high in upper 70's and low in lower 70's. Overall, everything I had joped for and more
Joan S. Dec 2018
Such a wonderful & convenient location. We kept our boat right by the townhouse. The rental was very comfortable for our family. The pool and grounds were also awesome. Fabulous hosts that were quick to follow up on questions. We hope to be back!
Donna E. Aug 2018
Marina was clean and condo beautiful View of the Bay was amazing Water was clear and great breeze off the water at night Just an amazing place Loved the ice machine and short run to the back country as well as the Atlantic
Jesus V. Jul 2018
Brian T. Jul 2018
Fantastic property. Great location. Easy boat launch on property and dockage right in front of where we stayed. Bayside with easy access to the Atlantic.
Dan M. Jul 2018
I really don't want to tell anyone how great this property was so I can keep it all to my self lol Owners were very easy to communicate with I did not want to leave a perfect location with a boat slip housr was super clean and exactly what was advertised
Chris S. Jun 2018
This beautiful condo is a real gem in the heart of Islamorada! On arrival, the gate attendant was very helpful and explained the grounds very well. The condo was cool and inviting and we were quite impressed with how the unit was furnished and decorated. From a fisherman’s perspective, this place is AWESOME. The dockage is exactly 14 paces from the ice machine and 13 paces from the bait freezer. Additionally, the private fish cleaning table has a drink holder! The owners have thought of nearly everything. Casa Caya is convenient to some of the best restaurants and shopping in the Upper Keys. I recommend visiting Ocean Gardens (nautical accessories and furnishings on ocean side MM 82) if you want to double the cost of your trip. LOL! Don’t miss the sunset celebration at Lorelei and have a Key Lime Colada for dessert. Marker 88 is within walking distance and is another great venue for sunset drinks. If breakfast before fishing is your thing, Mangrove Mikes is good and is not far from Tiny’s or Fishing Headquarters, where you can buy last minute bait! If breakfast at the condo is more your thing, I understand that Casa Cayo has a shiny, new toaster that should provide many years of reliable service! I would like to thank the owners for allowing us to stay in their little piece of heaven. We will be back if this place isn’t booked through eternity!!
Scott J. Mar 2018
This place has everything you need for a boating family. Ice machine, microfridge and bait freezer in the carport are priceless if you will be spending time on the water during your stay. the community is very clean and has all the necessities. We will be back.
Joelle F. Mar 2018
We had a great stay and would recommend this property to anyone looking for a relaxing stay in the Keys! The home, marina, and amenities were as described. We saw more marine life in the marina than on any other trip...manatee, tarpon, shark, lobster, crab and tons of fish. Any communications with the owners were promptly answered. It was a true pleasure!
Josh D. Dec 2017
Not sure where to start here, this was an amazing trip for us. I’ll start with The host, Jennifer. I can’t speak too much about communication because I didn’t need get in touch with her. Everything was just as she described and laid out in a wonderful welcome letter that covered everything we needed to know during our stay. It’s obvious she put a lot of time into making sure her guests are well informed about the townhouse, the marina and the surrounding area. The few times I did email her while booking she was very fast responding and when I inquired about extending my stay (because we didn’t want to leave) she was also very quick with response. Overall, she was a pleasure to deal with. The townhouse itself was amazing! Very well decorated, very clean and very comfortable. There is an ice maker, chest freezer and small refrigerator located in the carport for guests who have fish, bait, etc. This was one of my favorite perks of this townhouse. No late night or early morning trips to gas station to get ice for boat coolers. Her ice machine puts out more than enough to cover anything you might need ice for. The marina here is also top notch. It’s very spacious and I had no trouble at all docking my 30’ boat at the slip. The marina also had a lot of wildlife. While we were there we saw several manatee, plenty of fish including tarpon and one evening there were dolphin in there feeding on a school of mullet and putting on quite a show. The complex is also very nice. It’s very laid back and relaxed and everybody we met was very friendly. I loved this place! I can’t wait to go back, I just returned home but am already trying to plan my next trip there. If you’re thinking about spending time in Islamorada, rent this place and you will not be disappointed. Thanks for helping us have an amazing trip Jennifer!!! Looking forward to next time!!!
Sherry T. Jul 2017
We rented this townhome for one week and we were so happy! The location of Futura is perfect! The sandbar, Islamorada Fish Co., Holiday Isle Tiki Bar, and fishing are just a few minutes away! Having the ice maker, freezer and fridge downstairs was a life saver! We spent a lot of time hanging out downstairs playing ring toss because the breeze that comes thru is amazing! The townhouse is beautiful! Everything is new, comfy beds, and huge closets with lots of storage. It was so convenient having the boat ramp right there also! Usually we have to drive to Founders Park and put the boat in (and pay $20) then drive back to where we are staying- The boat slip is right outside your door which was so nice! Every day there was a new surprise next to our boat- manatee, lobster, barracuda, angel fish, tarpon, etc! It was very cool. I am so happy that we chose this rental and we will definitely stay here again!!!!
Gary G. Jun 2017
Jennifer's place was absolutely amazing. It was a fishermans paradise. Came fully furnished and newly renovated, place for docking your boat, filet table, ice machine, deep freezer and mini fridge. The condo was more than expected and made our vacation perfect. We will defiantly be coming back next year!
Bernita S. Feb 2017
We rented for a month in Feb 2017. The grounds are spectacular, and location is good for many restaurants and bars within 5 miles. Several are walkable. The condo is beautifully done with everything you could want. Comfy beds & living room furniture. Well stocked kitchen w/reg coffee maker and also a Kuerig. Dining seating for 6. Wifi & HD cable tv. California closets in bedrooms. Roman shower in master bath. Washer/dryer in unit. Waterfront sunset views every night from your balcony. They even provide beach towels and 2 paddle boards for your use. Would def stay here again.
John D. Jan 2017
The townhouse was in excellent shape and very clean. The owners (Jennifer and Louis) have done a wonderful job making our stay easy and relaxing by having an entire list of local restaurants, sports rentals, etc. We plan on returning!
Robert M. Sep 2016
It was truly an amazing experience for my family and I to stay at Casa Cayo. The place is fully set up for you to relax and/or go boating/fishing. The owner's have thought of everything you need in order for your stay to be wonderful. The boat slip is just steps away from the apartment which was very convenient. As I mentioned to Jen, I will certainly be back.
Matthew R. Jul 2016
We really enjoyed our time at this unit. We go to the keys every year and this year was a blast. The ice machine, deep freeze, and boat slip made things very convenient. The owners were very responsive and available to us as well.
Bill E. Jun 2016
We had a great time staying here. This is the second stay at Futura. This property will not disappoint.
Sam B. Jun 2016
Casa De Caya at the Futura Yacht club was fantastic even though there was some building repairs going on the staff and the owner were very accommodating we look forward to coming back.
Eric J. Apr 2016
Great week at Casa Cayo! Jen and Luis were really easy to work with, very helpful and very nice people. Was really windy the week we stayed but the inshore fishing was still a lot of fun! If you are bringing down a boat, the marina is first rate. The slip is right out in front of the townhouse so you can keep an eye on your things. The fish cleaning station was handy to have as well as a hose to wash the boat down with fresh water after you have been out. The ice machine is also really nice to have. It puts out plenty of ice and is very easy to shut it down and clean it out at the end of the week. One of the nicest things is the ramp. We have gone down to this general area for several years now and this is by far the best and safest ramp we have come across and there is plenty of parking for your trailer. The accommodations are also first rate. The place is in great shape and decorated nicely. The beds are comfortable and having cable and wifi is really nice. It's very clean, no mold or mildew anywhere which is rare down there. We didn't have to run the AC much the week we were there but when we did it cooled the place down quickly. The kitchen has everything you need but if your going to cook, bring your spices. The neighbors are all very friendly and helpful. It's a great value and worth every penny!! Thanks to Jen and Luis for a wonderful, care free vacation!! We will be back
Amanda B. Feb 2016
This was our first trip to the keys and we loved it. Wouldn't change anything. The house was great. Very clean and comfortable and Jen was very helpful. It had everything we needed and it was really handy to have the washer and dryer. In a great location with stunning views over the bay. The pool was great and the kids loved that they could play tennis and basketball. We have already recommended it to friends. An all round amazing holiday and if we ever make it to the keys again will definitely want to stop here again.!
Anonymous . Feb 2016
This condo is very pretty and very well maintained. It was very clean. There was plenty of comfortable seating in the living room and the dining room. The view from both floors was beautiful. The master bed was very comfortable. We didn't use the other bedroom but there were 3 beds in it and still plenty of room to move about in it. Air conditioning worked beautifully. Internet hookup was easy and worked great. The kitchen was well stocked and clean. All of the appliances, including washer & dryer, worked perfectly. Jen also had a couple of tennis racquets & lots of games on the shelves. I have nothing negative to say about this rental or Jen. She sent us lots of detailed instructions on how things worked and gave us many recommendations for restaurants & things to do nearby. We ate at a lot of the places she recommended and they were all very good. However - don't go to Loreli's for breakfast. Not so good. The pool at Futura is very nice and the people were all very friendly. There is a nice marina and boat ramp on the premises. I would come back here in a heartbeat and I would recommend this condo to everybody, including fishermen as this condo is fully equipped with a nice ice maker, filet table & boat dock (extra fee?) There is also a nice high top table & chairs down in the car port area. You definitely get what you pay for in this unit! The only minor disappointment we had was that there wasn't a tv in the master bedroom. When I inquired about it before I rented, I was told that there would be one in there before we got there. But that certainly didn't make our stay miserable. Just a slight inconvenience.
Jillian R. Dec 2015
Casa Cayo is the perfect island getaway! This was my family's first trip to the Key's, and we couldn't have been happier with our choice of this rental. My Mom traveled with us, and she has been to the Key's several times, Casa Cayo is her favorite rental place by far. Our trip started off bumpy, with cancelled flights and a 1,400 mile care trip, but Jennifer went above and beyond to ensure my family had a perfect vacation. The town home is very clean, comfortable, and updated. The property Futura Yacht Club is gorgeous! We will return to Casa Caya again and again!
May Lou C. Nov 2015
wow! What an amazing property! We've been coming down to the keys several years now and have stayed at many different places on all the different islands. Just wish I had found Jen's place years ago! Her thoughtful touches are evident throughout the entire home. From quality bath products to board games, sports equipment, gorgeous fluffy pool towels .. I could go on and on. The decor is the nicest I've seen, and my husband and I have traveled extensively throughout the US staying in VRBO rentals along the way. The master bathroom shower was a dream to come home to each night! The bedroom was such a treat in the morning to awaken to an incredible view of the bay right outside your window! We loved the pool, hardly anyone else was in there anytime we went. Everything from the home to the grounds was impeccible and clean. Loved the small beach - perfect place to watch the sunset each night. Such a lovely place to vacation! We plan on coming back every year! Thanks so much Jen, you created the perfect vacation getaway!
Dustin E. Oct 2015
We had a great stay and the owners went above and beyond for anything that we needed. They even put a pack in play in one of the rooms in advance for our 9 month old daughter! It was was in walking distance of several places and we had a short car/cab ride to even more options. We went to Key West one day and were grateful that we stayed where we did as it fit our relaxing pace much better.
John P. Jul 2015
Our stay was fantastic at the Futura Yacht club at Jennifer's place. If you are into fishing and water sports in the keys this is the spot to reserve, very comfortable townhouse in excellant shape with a great view of Florida Bay. Having an ice machine and deep freeze was the ultimate advantage for us in the Florida heat. A yeti cooler full of dolphin to take home would not have happened if not for staying here.