Five Fire Island vacation rentals raising the bar for beach house luxury

Back deck of Fire Island vacation rental
light interior of Fire Island, NY vacation rental home

Just off the southern shore of Long Island, Fire Island is only accessible by ferry (no cars allowed!), and that’s how residents and visitors like it. Guests book Fire Island vacation rentals to escape the hustle and bustle of city life and find a bit of beachside luxury. And with amenities like private pools, spacious patios, gourmet kitchens, and impeccable interior design, our Fire Island beach house rentals offer just the respite they’re looking for.

If you’ve been daydreaming about a sunny vacation, take a look at a few of our favorite Fire Island beach houses and find your own slice of the good life.

560 Bayberry Fire Island beach house rental

Soak up the sun at this luxurious Fire Island vacation rental, whether you’re sunbathing on the spacious patio or relaxing in the living room with a novel. You can’t get much closer to the waves than this: Ocean Beach’s soft sand is just two houses down. Don’t forget to take advantage of the boogie boards and bikes provided during your stay!

Book your next Fire Island vacation rental at 560 Bayberry.

29 Evergreen Fire Island beach house rental

You don’t often see homes this chic available for rent—this Seaview beach house rental is truly a treasure! Plus, you’re welcome to bring your dog along, as this home is pet-friendly. A welcoming patio sets the scene for memorable summer dinners, and details like a Sonos speaker and gas stovetop range add an upscale touch to the experience.

Book your next Fire Island vacation rental at 29 Evergreen.

109 Bungalow Fire Island beach house rental

Don’t settle for less when it comes to your Fire Island house rental: book this upscale bungalow and treat yourself to a private pool, back deck, gas fireplace, and sunroom. The beach is just down the street, but if you’d rather rest in this home’s airy living room, we’d understand. Relaxation is the goal here!

Book your next Fire Island vacation rental at 109 Bungalow.

25 Ontario Fire Island beach house rental

For an upscale version of the classic coastal cabin, look no further than this cute Ocean Bay Park beach house rental. A sunny window seat will entice you to read (and possibly nap), and there’s room for everybody to sunbathe on the back deck. The refurbished wood interior and antique furniture set a delightfully cozy atmosphere for up to eight guests.

Book your next Fire Island vacation rental at 25 Ontario.

30 Surf View Fire Island beach house rental

Built in 1905, this historic house rental has been restored with all the modern bells and whistles in mind—it’s just waiting for you to visit. With a patio this pretty, you might be tempted to take brunch out in the garden every day! But don’t overlook the interior, complete with colorful design details and amenities like a gourmet kitchen and spa tubs in the bathrooms.

Book your next Fire Island vacation rental at 30 Surf View.

You might also like...

Waterfront vacation rental located at Moosehead Lake
Six charming New England waterfront vacation rentals
Kayak and bike rentals in Boothbay Harbor, Maine
Pet-friendly East Coast vacations your dog will love
Outdoor firepit in Warren, VT
Rekindle the flame at these seven romantic getaways in Vermont
Portland Lobster Co. lobster roll
Where to find the best lobster in Portland, Maine