Fire Island, NY House Rentals

Compare 33 vacation rentals.
USA > New York > Fire Island, NY

Make Fire Island, NY your next getaway

Beach-lovers from New York City and beyond know that when it starts to warm up in the spring, it’s time to make your Fire Island vacation rental reservation. This barrier island west of the Hamptons is a popular beach destination for all kinds of travelers---and for good reason. Soft beaches, walkable neighborhoods, and a relaxed vibe bring Fire Island visitors back year after year. With our high-end vacation rental offerings, you’ll find Fire Island to be a beautiful beach escape.

Explore Fire Island, NY house rentals, condo rentals, duplexes, and more


House rentals

View 22 House rentals

Condo rentals

View 4 Condo rentals


View 3 Duplexes

Popular amenities for Fire Island, NY vacation rentals

Dog-friendly Hot tub Internet
Huron Hideaway
3 Bedroom | 1.5 Bath | Sleeps 6

Huron Hideaway - Ocean Bay Park, NY

$776 avg / night
Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat
5 Bedroom | 1.5 Bath | Sleeps 12

Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat - Ocean Bay Park, NY

$641 avg / night
15 Seneca
3 Bedroom | 2 Bath | Sleeps 10

15 Seneca - Ocean Bay Park, NY

$1,211 avg / night
Fire Island Gem
2 Bedroom | 1 Bath | Sleeps 5

Fire Island Gem - Ocean Bay Park, NY

$356 avg / night
Surfside Retreat On Champlain Street
2 Bedroom | 1 Bath | Sleeps 9

Surfside Retreat On Champlain Street - Ocean Bay Park, NY

$398 avg / night

View 28 more homes

Recent Fire Island, NY guest reviews

The Reteela Retreat was perfect for our stay in Fire Island. It is centrally located and even more beautiful than the pictures.
MARGARET M. | Sep 2023
Perfect location to all.
Billy S. | Sep 2023
The houses is beautiful and spacious ! Had so much fun!! Can sleep so many people! Really great location!!!!
John L. | Sep 2023
Fire Island, NY vacation rental FAQ

Yes, 17 of our Fire Island, NY homes allow dogs—so feel free to bring Fido along. (Just make sure to check individual home listings for any limits on the number and size of dogs they allow).

Browse dog-friendly homes >

Yes. 33 of our Fire Island, NY vacation rentals have internet access, so you can stay connected throughout your trip.

Browse homes with internet access >

Some of the most popular amenities in our Fire Island, NY vacation rentals include:

Our standard check-in time is 4:00 p.m., and the check-out time is 10:00 a.m. Some exceptions apply—after you book, you’ll find check-in and check-out details in the Vacasa guest app or your Trip Manager.

Absolutely. Our local Fire Island, NY team includes professional housekeepers who care for all our homes here. They’ll clean thoroughly and restock amenities, so everything is ready for your arrival—and all you have to do is settle in and relax.

Learn more about Vacasa Premium Clean >

No worries, plans change. Read over our cancellation policy for more information. And if you currently have a Vacasa reservation for Fire Island, NY, log in to Trip Manager to see options available for your specific trip.

Book confidently. Stay comfortably.

Book confidently. Stay comfortably.
24/7 support
Easy check-in
Easy check-in
Professional cleaning
Professional cleaning

Where are our Fire Island beach house rentals?

A little over 60 miles east of New York City, Fire Island sits right offshore from Long Island, separated from it by the Great South Bay. To get to Fire Island, you’ll have to take the ferry: cars aren’t allowed on the island’s mostly residential 32 miles. The lack of cars makes for an extraordinarily laid-back and friendly atmosphere, as locals and vacation rental guests embrace a slower pace of life.

Things to do on Fire Island

When you’re on Fire Island, the best way to spend your day is often strolling or sunbathing on the beautiful beaches. Ocean Beach, the most populated and most visited part of the island, offers family-friendly beaches, cute boutiques, and a few local drinking and dining establishments. The Fire Island National Seashore boasts serene beaches and dunes perfect for exploring. Make sure to visit the Fire Island Lighthouse while you’re looking around. Robert Moses State Park and Smith Point County Park are must-visit spots for nature lovers, too.

Fall in love with Fire Island—book a vacation rental at this beautiful destination.