Long Island, NY Vacation Rentals

Compare 73 vacation rentals. Enter your trip dates to get started.
USA > New York > Long Island, NY

Make Long Island, NY your next getaway—choose from 73 great vacation rentals

Explore our Long Island vacation rentals

Explore Long Island, NY house rentals, duplexes, condo rentals, and more


House rentals

View 66 House rentals


View 3 Duplexes

Condo rentals

View 2 Condo rentals

Long Island, NY vacation rentals for every getaway

Dog-friendly Hot tub Internet
Cottage in the Hamptons
4 Bedroom | 3 Bath | Sleeps 10

Cottage in the Hamptons - Sag Harbor, NY

$767 avg / night
The Parkside Retreat in Noyac
3 Bedroom | 2.5 Bath | Sleeps 6

The Parkside Retreat in Noyac - Sag Harbor, NY

$319 avg / night
5 Bedroom | 2 Bath | Sleeps 10

Paradiso - Ocean Beach, NY

$2,166 avg / night
North Fork Waterfront Gem
2 Bedroom | 2 Bath | Sleeps 4

North Fork Waterfront Gem - East Marion, NY

$302 avg / night
Sag Harbor Serenity
4 Bedroom | 4.5 Bath | Sleeps 10

Sag Harbor Serenity - Sag Harbor, NY

$892 avg / night

View 68 more homes

Recent Long Island, NY vacation rental reviews

Booked this place for a quiet, long winter weekend with a friend and 6- and 9-year old nieces. Was concerned that the house might be a bit too rustic and outdated for my taste based on the photos, but it turned out to be the perfect place. The house is full of charm and character. The girls loved the decorations in their room, and they now want peach and dark blue sinks installed in their own house (retro fixtures are cool again--glad they had not been ripped out in some unnecessary/wasteful remodel and replaced with bland modern fixtures). All the furnishings were incredibly comfortable. Lots of room to spread out and read books or hang out together. Kitchen was ideal for everyone to help make dinner (delicious steaks and pork chops from Schiavoni's Market). All the right pots, pans, knives, plates and silverware. We played card games in the sofa bed room, board games on the living room coffee table in front of a cozy fire, and more games on the dining room table. We brought games with us, but the house was well-stocked with games the girls had never played before. Also did crafts on the kitchen island and the common area desk. Walked to the beach and collected shells, and hardly minded the brisk January wind. Enjoyed looking at the fascinating and varied architecture of other homes in the neighborhood during the short walk. Shopping in Sag Harbor was fun, with purchases of more toys and high quality Sag Harbor sweatshirts and ball caps. Girls never said they were bored the entire weekend! Already planning to come back in warmer weather (can't wait to play games on the deck).
Helen G. | Jan 2023
This well lit, well stocked cozy home in Sag Harbor provided the perfect getaway for us and our friends to enjoy all that Long Island has to offer. The home has a relaxing peaceful vibe with interesting artwork which we enjoyed. The floor plan is open and presents several areas to read and enjoy a glass of wine. We stayed for a long weekend in January and enjoyed visiting the wineries and vineyards on both forks (via a short drive and easy access to the ferry)! The traffic was minimal and the weather was pleasant. We were also able to walk to the private and public beaches and browse the shops downtown (only 1.2 mile on foot). We had never visited Sag Harbor but found it to be very charming with quaint shops and wonderful restaurants. We will be back in the summer to take full advantage of the beaches and the wonderful fresh seafood!!
Kim W. | Jan 2023
I stayed at Modern on 9th this past week and I couldn't be happier about the decision. The place was perfect and just as shown in photos and described. The host, Chanet has put so much detail into every corner of the home, from the decor to the house's layout (there are bathrooms for every bedroom, making it perfect for a girls trip or a couple's weekend), to her having everything that you could possible want or need during your stay (everything she has in her kitchen, you will want for your own home). It was the epitome of a luxury stay. I look forward to coming back the next time I am in the area.
Amanda M. | Dec 2022
Long Island, NY vacation rental FAQ

Yes, 41 of our Long Island, NY homes allow dogs—so feel free to bring Fido along. (Just make sure to check individual home listings for any limits on the number and size of dogs they allow).

Browse dog-friendly homes >

Yes. 73 of our Long Island, NY vacation rentals have internet access, so you can stay connected throughout your trip.

Browse homes with internet access >

Some of the most popular amenities in our Long Island, NY vacation rentals include:

Our standard check-in time is 4:00 p.m., and the check-out time is 10:00 a.m. Some exceptions apply—after you book, you’ll find check-in and check-out details in the Vacasa guest app or your Trip Manager.

Absolutely. Our local Long Island, NY team includes professional housekeepers who care for all our homes here. They’ll clean thoroughly and restock amenities, so everything is ready for your arrival—and all you have to do is settle in and relax.

Learn more about Vacasa Premium Clean >

No worries, plans change. Read over our cancellation policy for more information. And if you currently have a Vacasa reservation for Long Island, NY, log in to Trip Manager to see options available for your specific trip.

Book confidently. Stay comfortably.

Book confidently. Stay comfortably.
24/7 support
Easy check-in
Easy check-in
Professional cleaning
Professional cleaning

Enjoy the beach just a short distance from New York City when you book one of our Long Island beach houses. We offer homes all across Long Island, from Fire Island to Peconic Bay. Our Long Island vacation rentals offer amenities like private pools, hot tubs, and balconies overlooking the ocean—so you can soak up the sun in style.

What to do near your Long Island vacation rental

There are countless attractions to visit no matter where on Long Island you choose to stay. Fire Island sports the Fire Island Lighthouse and Robert Moses State Park—and, of course, the Fire Island National Seashore. If you decide to stay closer to the eastern tip of the island, Montauk, Sag Harbor, and other fashionable towns in the Hamptons boast excellent shops and restaurants. It's also worth visiting quiet and scenic spots like Cooper’s Beach and Hither Hills State Park. And of course, you can always venture into New York City if you need a taste of the concrete jungle.