Virtual Tour
USA New York Fire Island, NY Seaview Listing #21984

25 Fairway - Seaview, NY

5 reviews
Max occupancy: 10 2 Queen Bed, 3 Double Bed, 2 Twin Bed 5 bedrooms 3 bathrooms Dog-friendly 
25 Fairway Avenue, Seaview, NY 11770

Amazing home w/ private pool, spacious deck, separate cottage & more!

Conveniently located in the highly desirable Seaview community, this property is a great family getaway. The home features a spacious sun deck with a large swimming pool, main house, and guest house. The main house features three bedrooms (one queen size bed, one full, and a twin bunk bed), two full bathrooms, an updated kitchen, and a spacious living and dining area with bench style seating for 10 guests. The central air conditioning system will keep you cool and comfortable. The guest house has two bedrooms (one full bed, one twin bunk bed) with a Jack and Jill full bathroom with windowed shower. The property is fully fenced and very private. The deck has just recently finished up with a large update as well!

What's nearby:
This home is located in Seaview, a highly desirable family friendly community that features lifeguarded beaches, tennis courts, basketball court, baseball field, bay beach, playground, and kiddie pool. Seaview has direct ferry service from Bay Shore, a gourmet market, wine shop, and plant shop.

Things to know:
This home is only accessible via ferry
This home has a strict 30 year-old minimum age requirement. This rule does not apply to families with children.
Free WiFi
There are strict good neighbor and noise policies for this home in addition to no parties allowed at any time

This property is managed by Susan Scanlon, Principal Real Estate Broker with Vacasa New York, LLC

Property tax ID: 2037



Washer/dryer : Private

Heating & cooling

Central AC

Kitchen & dining









Nearby activities & attractions


On-site activities

Pool : Private

Adult bikes

Tennis court : Shared

Basketball court : Shared


Gas grill : Private


Beach chairs


5 reviews

John S. Aug 2019
We had a fantastic stay at this house. We felt so lucky to be staying in such a nice house in Fire Island, knowing how many junky rentals there are. All three bathrooms are newly renovated. Updated kitchen, nice wood floors, everything well labeled (lights, Linen closet), New washer/dryer. Everything was very clean. Beautiful pool & landscaping. Location cannot be beat, about six blocks off of Ocean Beach and about three minute walk to the ocean.
Lawrence H. Aug 2018
My wife and our two sons just spent a lovely week at this house in Seaview. This is our 5th time renting a house on Fire Island. Overall we had a great time. The pool and the recently redone deck is lovely. The pool house has two small guest rooms with a small bathroom in between and is quite comfortable, just not attached to the main house. In between is a terrific outdoor shower.The main house is very nice but also pretty small. Especially the kitchen which is a galley more than a kitchen. it's well equipped and has nice appliances but it's impossible to get more than 2 people in there at once. if you open the fridge, nobody can get by! Also, the coffee maker is a Keurig so you need to bring pods! It's not a drip maker as is in description.There are 3 small bedrooms and 2 small, but full, baths. The house was recently renovated, and looks brand new and they did a nice job. Except there are details missing like: towel bars or hooks in any of the bathrooms. Toilet paper holders.bedside tables or bedside lamps for reading. (Had to get out of bed each night to turn out the lights). I think if they can add these few missing items the house will be a real winner. BIG TV screen, and TV's in all 3 bedrooms. Excellent AC and overhead fans. Great location, just a half a block from the bay and 2 blocks to the fabulous Seaview Market. The one bedroom at the front of the house did get some noise as it's a major thoroughfare between the store/ferry and the rest of Seaview. The ocean is 2 avenues away. About a 5-6 minute walk. But it's a pretty walk and doesn't feel very far. Overall it's a very comfortable house, that with a few more details added, will be top notch.
Owen W. Jul 2018
We had a GREAT time at 25 Fairway. We're already looking forward to renting the same property next summer.
I'm very particular about cleanliness.I was disappointed but didn't mind cleaning door glass, trash cans, and floors when I arrived. I did my best to ignore the cobwebs in the living room high ceiling.
We thought it was weird that there were no towel or toilet paper holders but it was no issue
Overall it was a
Kim P. Jul 2017
My family had a wonderful time. The house is a minute walk from the ferry and a five minute walk to Ocean Beach's restaurants and shopping and a 10 minute walk from Ocean Bay Park. The pool was a huge plus after spending the day at the beach. The house was beautifully renovated and included many extras, such as cable, bicycles, beach chairs and beach towels, just to name a few. I would love to spent more time there in the future.