New Buffalo Vacation Rentals

Compare 20 vacation rentals.
1 Guest
USA > Michigan > New Buffalo

Make New Buffalo your next getaway

Michigan’s Harbor Country is a hidden gem among lakeside getaways. This constellation of small towns and villages, spanning 15 miles along the shores of Lake Michigan, is a beloved destination of many vacationers. Experience this special place for yourself when you book one of our New Buffalo vacation rentals.

Explore New Buffalo house rentals, cottages, and more

housing_type_house.jpg

House rentals

View 19 House rentals
housing_type_cottage.jpg

Cottages

View 1 Cottages

Popular amenities for New Buffalo vacation rentals

Popular
Dog-friendly Hot tub Internet
The Tree House
2 Bedroom | 2.5 Bath | Sleeps 6

The Tree House - New Buffalo, MI

$284 avg / night
(excludes fees and taxes)
4.82 (22)
Anchors Away
2 Bedroom | 2 Bath | Sleeps 8

Anchors Away - New Buffalo, MI

$244 avg / night
(excludes fees and taxes)
4.26 (27)
Livywood Cottage
2 Bedroom | 2 Bath | Sleeps 6

Livywood Cottage - New Buffalo, MI

$244 avg / night
(excludes fees and taxes)
5.0 (13)
Hydrangea House
3 Bedroom | 2 Bath | Sleeps 6

Hydrangea House - New Buffalo, MI

$235 avg / night
(excludes fees and taxes)
4.48 (25)
Nothin Dune
5 Bedroom | 3 Bath | Sleeps 10

Nothin Dune - New Buffalo, MI

$1,409 avg / night
(excludes fees and taxes)
4.77 (30)

View 15 more homes

Recent New Buffalo guest reviews

Our family of 14 - aged 14 to 85 - had an incredible time at Sandcastle. Each person said WOW when they entered the house! The common areas (inside and outside) and bedrooms were abundant and very comfortable. The kitchen is extremely well stocked to be able to cook and clean up large family meals. I was delighted with the stocking of toilet paper, paper towels, kitchen essentials, and starter dishwashing/laundry packs...what a kindness...as well as the beach chairs and towels which were provided. And bath towels! And games! (Our young adults/teens played board games well into the night while the older crew remarkably was able to sleep upstairs undisturbed.) So many things were considered for the comfort of guests in this home, and we were incredibly grateful. And I haven't even mentioned the incredible location and views - the beach was spectacular and the proximity to New Buffalo just right...away from the beach crowds but close enough to walk to fun restaurants and shops. We would absolutely choose to stay here again - thank you!!
Chenoweth A. | Jul 2025
Cozy, Golf cart a HUGE plus, patio, TV, Games, towels and overall location close to Michigan City (beach, shopping)- wish we could stay longer.
Kristin O. | Jun 2025
Beautiful home. Conveniently located near public beach access and walking distance to local shops and restaurants. Fun for everyone! Will definitely return!
Mary Clare P. | Jun 2025
New Buffalo vacation rental FAQ

Yes, 5 of our New Buffalo homes allow dogs—so feel free to bring Fido along. (Just make sure to check individual home listings for any limits on the number and size of dogs they allow).

Browse dog-friendly homes >

Yes. 74 of our New Buffalo vacation rentals have internet access, so you can stay connected throughout your trip.

Browse homes with internet access >


Some of the most popular amenities in our New Buffalo vacation rentals include:

Our standard check-in time is 4:00 p.m., and the check-out time is 10:00 a.m. Some exceptions apply—after you book, you’ll find the check-in and check-out details in the Vacasa guest app or your Trip Manager.

Absolutely. Our local New Buffalo team includes professional housekeepers who care for all our homes here. They’ll clean thoroughly and restock amenities, so everything is ready for your arrival—and all you have to do is settle in and relax.

Learn more about Vacasa Premium Clean >

No problem, plans can change. For more information, please read our cancellation policy. If you have a Vacasa reservation for New Buffalo, log in to Trip Manager to explore the options available for your specific trip.

Book confidently. Stay comfortably.

Vacasa Guest Value Prop icon: 24-7
24/7 guest service
Vacasa Guest Value Prop Icon check-in
Seamless check-in
Vacasa Guest Value Prop Icons cleaning
Professional cleaning

Where is New Buffalo, MI?

Harbor Country is the gateway to Michigan, especially for travelers heading northeast on Interstate 94. Just 70 miles from downtown Chicago, the town of New Buffalo is just moments off the highway, but feels completely separated from the hustle and bustle. New Buffalo is the largest of the eight communities that make up Harbor Country, offering plenty of activities for the whole family or just a romantic getaway.

Things to do in New Buffalo, MI

Visitors flock to our New Buffalo cabin rentals to slow down and savor the beauty of Lake Michigan. With the largest public beach in the entire Harbor Country region, this town is a popular spot for doing just that. Spend a sunny afternoon playing on the sand, use the launch area for a boating adventure, or swim in the waters. Lake Michigan is enormous, and it’s easy to forget you aren’t actually on the ocean as the wind gently whips up small white-caps.

Galien River County Park is a great spot for a morning jog, bird-watching stroll, or kayak adventure. Trails meander through trees and over marshland, and there’s even a playground for the kids to enjoy. In the autumn, it’s a stress-free way to access some beautiful foliage as the flat trails pass through tunnels of trees.

Be sure to stroll along the harbor—the largest in the aptly-named Harbor Country—and stop at the Stray Dog Bar and Grill. This New Buffalo staple rests right on the water, where you can watch the comings and goings of boats as you dine on anything from burgers to pizza to tacos. In the warmer months, the rooftop bar is open, where you can enjoy a cocktail paired with spectacular lakeside sunsets.

Lake Michigan’s Harbor Country is a truly special place. If you’re seeking respite from the hecticness of everyday life, book one of our New Buffalo vacation rentals today.

New Buffalo vacation inspiration 

9 weekend trips from Chicago that are worth the drive

Su
Mo
Tu
We
Th
Fr
Sa
29
30
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
1
2