New Buffalo vacation rentals with pools

We found 6 vacation rentals waiting for you.

Find your ultimate splash pad

From plunge pools for a quick dip to infinity pools with a view, here are the New Buffalo vacation homes where you can dive in, cool off, and catch some sun.

Top-rated New Buffalo rentals with pools

Our guests have spoken. Explore their favorite and top-rated homes in New Buffalo with refreshing pools, sun-splashed decks, and poolside seating.

Anchors Away
2 Bed | 2 Bath | Sleeps 8

Anchors Away - New Buffalo, MI

From $243
(excludes fees and taxes)
4.26 (27)
Leisure On The Lake
6 Bed | 4.5 Bath | Sleeps 16

Leisure On The Lake - New Buffalo, MI

From $1,362
(excludes fees and taxes)
4.64 (11)
Charlotte’s Chateau
5 Bed | 3 Bath | Sleeps 14

Charlotte’s Chateau - New Buffalo, MI

From $610
(excludes fees and taxes)
4.2 (5)
Merchant Street Pool Retreat
3 Bed | 2 Bath | Sleeps 8

Merchant Street Pool Retreat - New Buffalo, MI

From $616
(excludes fees and taxes)
4.58 (24)

Explore All Vacation Rentals With Pools

Recent guest reviews

The location is fantastic! You really can walk to everything! The hot tub was super relaxing and there were plenty of beach towels. Unfortunately, because of the weather we weren’t able to check out the pool- maybe next time!
Tia L. | May 2025
We loved the location and the quiet street. We enjoyed the privacy of the hot tub with the fenced in yard . The home is within walking distance to everything even in the cooler weather and it was clean, comfortable and fully stocked with everything we needed. We appreciated the books and games & enjoyed sitting around the dining room table together. We'd definitely book again in the summer to enjoy the pool. The lake is just a short walk too.
Jack O. | Feb 2025
We had a fantastic stay at this house! Perfectly suited for our family of 5. The spacious layout allowed for everyone to relax in their own spaces and be together when we needed to be. The kids loved the backyard (and we all loved the hot tub!) and the nearby beaches. The public beach is nice and close to ice cream shops, lunch spots, etc. The house is in walking distance to the main strip for shopping and eating with our favorite restaurant being Beer Church Brewery (family friendly). Very much recommend for families or large groups looking for a fun getaway!
Megan S. | Oct 2024
Lovely place for a getaway with friends!
Brigid C. | Oct 2024
Best pricing

Book directly on Vacasa.com for the lowest rates.

3D virtual tours

Know exactly what you’re booking—no surprises.

Seamless check-in

Check in easily and quickly with a digital code.

Expert cleaning

Arrive to a spotless home with fresh linens.

FAQ

Our vacation rentals offer both private and shared pools. Each property’s listing description will specify whether the pool offered is private or shared.

Every home is stocked with plenty of towels. However, the availability of pool towels varies by property.

Some pools are heated, and there may be an additional fee for this service. You can find more information about heating fees in the property description.

Yes, pool maintenance is included during your stay. We ensure that pools and hot tubs are regularly cleaned and maintained to provide an optimal experience. If you encounter any issues with the pool during your stay, contact our Guest Experience team immediately.

Many of our properties include lounge chairs, umbrellas, or shaded areas by the pool, but this can vary. Check the property details and listing photos for specific details.

Generally, food and drinks are allowed by—but not in—the pool. However, to be safe, it’s best not to use glass or china in the pool area.

Pool toys, floaties, or inflatables are typically not provided. You may want to bring your own, if needed.

Some properties include a poolside grill or outdoor kitchen area, but this is not standard across all rentals. Check the property listing for details.

We have a good neighbor policy that includes quiet hours from 10 p.m. to 8 a.m. In addition, certain communities have noise policies in place. Unauthorized parties are not allowed, and excessive noise can lead to intervention and removal from a property.

If you encounter any issues with the pool during your stay, contact our Guest Experience team immediately. Your local Vacasa team will work to resolve the problem as quickly as possible.

Not all pools are open all year round. Some pools—depending on the destination—are seasonal only. Read the listing description for specific operating times for the pool.

More ways to stay in New Buffalo

Dog-friendly
Hot tub
Internet
Electric vehicle charger
Lake view
Lakefront
Water view
Waterfront

Nearby destinations

Great Lakes
Lake Michigan
Western Michigan
Southwest Michigan
Grand Beach
Union Pier
Michiana
Lakeside
USA > Michigan > New Buffalo > Pool