Second home vs. investment property search tips

Advice from Vacasa Real Estate

Whether you’re looking for a second home or the right investment property for short-term rental income, a vacation home search can be very exciting. When you begin, everything feels possible. But, without the right approach, it’s easy to get caught up in the romance of searching and start to feel burned out by search overload or decision fatigue.


Second home vs. investment property considerations

It’s important to be thoughtful and efficient when you look for a property, structuring your vacation home search around your priorities and how you hope to use your vacation home:

  • Why are you searching for a vacation home in the first place? What kinds of experiences and benefits are you looking for?
  • Will this be a vacation home for you today, or in the future when you retire?
  • Are you planning to share the home and turn it into an investment property that you can rent to short-term guests?
  • Will your home primarily be a piece of real estate to diversify your investment portfolio?

Once you’re clear on your goals, you can make a prioritized list of your needs, wants, and deal breakers. Or, if you’re not yet sure about your goals, your list of needs, wants, and deal breakers can help you better understand your interest in owning a second home vs. an investment property.


Needs are your must-haves

Think about the number of bedrooms and bathrooms, square footage, floor plan considerations, and other features that can’t be easily changed. If you're looking for a second home for personal use, it's important to think about what you need to feel comfortable. If you're aiming for an investment property, you might prioritize having extra space to accommodate a larger group of guests.

It’s not a bad idea to start mapping out your financial needs now, too. What’s your budget? How might that budget change if you could offset your mortgage or property taxes with short-term rental income?

By the way, there’s no cause for worry if you’re not sure about these numbers. Few people are at this stage. Talking with an expert vacation home real estate agent can help you understand what’s available in markets you’re interested in, or find a market that would meet your budget and income goals. Together, you can weigh the pros and cons of a second home vs. an investment property.

Wants are your nice-to-haves

When you’re looking at a second home vs. a vacation rental investment property, think of your nice-to-haves as the features you may have to compromise on.

Things like views, a chef's kitchen, ample parking, lot size, flexible accessibility, and space for vacation-friendly (and revenue boosting) upgrades, like a hot tub, should be on this list.

Your wants can also include community amenities like beach or pool access; recreational opportunities like golf, skiing, and local attractions; and proximity to restaurants and resorts.

Whether you're buying a second home or an investment property, consider the property's proximity to things you love to do on vacation—since those features will also appeal to your family, friends, and potential guests.

Many vacation homes will have most of the features you want, but this is the part of your list where a prioritized list of your wants will matter most.

What amenities make your home most desirable for you, guests, and even other buyers? (After all, someday you may want to sell or trade up in a 1031 exchange.) What are the nice-to-haves that can be traded away for other benefits?


Deal breakers help you know when to say no

You might find a home that’s exactly what you’re looking for except for one unavoidable problem: Is there a biker bar on the other side of the fence? Can you hear freight trains or significant road noise from the home? Is there a beautiful pond… that’s always filled with honking geese? Even if the house is otherwise perfect, identifying something that’s a personal deal breaker means it’s time to keep looking.

Also consider the vacation rental climate in the locations you’re searching. There may be some financial factors that reveal unexpected deal breakers:

  • How friendly are the vacation rental regulations?
  • Is there a wait list for new permits?
  • How fast is the region or community growing?
  • How far away from your initial search location are you willing to look in order to find a top market for buying?

It can be helpful to consider how much you’re willing to invest in improvements and upgrades, too. Some buyers like the idea of investing in a fixer-upper, and there are some clear pros and cons to doing so—especially if you’re leaning more toward buying a vacation rental investment property.


One last thing…

It’s a good idea to reconcile your list of priorities with those of any other people involved in this purchase, like a spouse, partner, or sibling. It helps to have everyone in agreement and aligned to the same goals. Defining your priorities up front, together, makes it easier to make an objective decision later.


Work with an expert agent to start your vacation home search right and understand the advantages of buying a second home vs. an investment property.

Read more: Finding and optimizing your vacation rental



Vacasa offers property management and other real estate services directly through Vacasa LLC and through Vacasa LLC's licensed subsidiaries. Click here for more information about Vacasa's licensed real estate brokerage/property manager in your state. Vacasa’s licensed real estate brokerages/property managers include: Vacasa Alabama LLC; Vacasa Arizona LLC; Vacasa Florida LLC; Vacasa Louisiana L.L.C. (licensed in Louisiana); Vacasa Michigan LLC, 947-800-5979; Vacasa Nevada LLC; Vacasa New Hampshire LLC, P.O. Box 283, Conway NH 03818, Dave Grant, Broker of Record; Vacasa New Mexico LLC, 503-345-9399; Vacasa New York LLC, 888-433-0068, Susan E. Scanlon, Real Estate Broker; Vacasa North Carolina LLC; Vacasa Pennsylvania LLC; Vacasa Real Estate LLC (licensed in Idaho and Oregon); Vacasa Real Estate LLC (licensed in Colorado, 720-727-9358); Vacasa Real Estate LLC (licensed in Washington, Robert Brush, Designated Broker); Vacasa Resort Rentals of Hilton Head Island LLC; Vacasa South Carolina LLC; Vacasa Tennessee LLC; Vacasa Vacation Rentals of Hawaii LLC, 3350 Lower Honoapiilani Road, Suite 600, Lahaina, HI 96761; Vacasa Vacation Rentals of Montana LLC, Rickie Miller, Licensed Property Manager; Vacasa Virginia LLC; Vacasa Wisconsin LLC.

*This document is for information and illustrative purposes only. It is not intended to provide “investment advice” or a “recommendation” regarding a course of action. The discussion is general in nature and has not taken into account your personal financial position or objectives. You should consult a licensed financial advisor or other professional to discuss your specific situation.